> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.greeninsider.org/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Your green tariff probably does not make your Scope 2 zero
- URL: https://www.greeninsider.org/green-tariff-rego-scope-2-market-based/
- Published: 2026-11-14T15:53:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-21T00:09:37.000Z
- Description: A green tariff only zeroes market-based Scope 2 if certificates are cancelled for you. What to report, what to ask your supplier, and what changes next.
- Author: Veljko Plavšić
- Tags: Clean Energy, Fundamentals

**Short answer.** A green tariff can bring your market-based Scope 2 figure to zero, but only if energy attribute certificates are cancelled against your own consumption, for the same period, in the country where you use the power. It never changes your location-based figure, which is the one most small-company questionnaires and the voluntary SME standard ask for. Ask your supplier for written proof before you report zero.

*Checked on 15 November 2026\. Sources and unresolved points are in the method note at the end.*

Renewable electricity is the claim small companies make most confidently and defend least well. The contract says green, the invoice says green, and the questionnaire box says zero. Whether that zero survives a customer's review depends on paperwork most buyers have never seen.

## Key takeaways

- **Scope 2 has two numbers.** Location-based and market-based, reported side by side.
- **Tariffs only touch market-based.** Your location-based figure stays exactly the same.
- **Certificates must be cancelled for you.** Possession or supplier marketing is not enough.
- **Timing and country matter.** Cancellation must match your consumption period and market.
- **Hourly matching is delayed.** GHG Protocol plans a further consultation in 2027.

---

## Why does Scope 2 have two numbers?

Because the GHG Protocol Scope 2 Guidance, published in 2015, requires companies that operate in markets with contractual instruments to report both a location-based and a market-based figure. Europe is such a market, so a European company reporting Scope 2 properly reports twice.

The location-based method multiplies your electricity use by the average emission factor of the grid you draw from. It describes the physical system, and nothing you sign changes it.

The market-based method reflects the contracts you hold. Electricity covered by valid certificates can carry a zero factor, and everything else takes the residual mix, which is the grid average with all claimed renewable power removed and is therefore usually higher than the grid average.

That second detail is the one that surprises people. A company with no green contract can report a market-based figure higher than its location-based one, because the renewable share of the grid has already been claimed by others.

---

## What makes a green tariff claim valid?

The certificates behind it. In the EU these are guarantees of origin, and in Great Britain they are Renewable Energy Guarantees of Origin, which sit outside the European system and cannot simply be swapped for EU certificates.

The Scope 2 Guidance sets quality criteria for any instrument used in a market-based figure. In practical terms, four conditions decide whether your zero holds.

1. **Cancelled for you.** The certificates must be cancelled, also called retired or redeemed, by you or on your behalf, so nobody else can claim the same megawatt hours.
2. **Matched in time.** Cancellation should be as close as possible to the period of consumption. Under the Renewable Energy Directive a guarantee of origin is valid for 12 months after production, and national registries set their own cancellation deadlines within that framework.
3. **Same market.** Certificates should come from the market where you consume, and cross-border certificates must be transferred and cancelled in the registry of the country of consumption.
4. **Unique.** The same output cannot be counted in your supplier's general fuel mix and again in your tariff.

National practice varies more than most buyers expect. French rules require cancellation against consumption in the corresponding production month, so a single year-end cancellation is not sufficient there, while the Netherlands allows cancellation for disclosure up to 12 months after the production month.

The gap between a valid and an invalid claim is rarely visible on the invoice. It sits in a registry entry your supplier controls, which is why the same evidence logic applies here as to any [supplier sustainability questionnaire](https://www.greeninsider.org/customer-sustainability-questionnaire-what-to-do-first/): the claim is only as good as the document behind it.

---

## What can each arrangement let you report?

The table below covers the electricity setups a small company is most likely to have. The right column matters for later years, because the proposed stricter method would change what some of them are worth.

| Arrangement                                                    | Location-based Scope 2             | Market-based Scope 2                                   | Evidence to hold                                                | Exposure if hourly matching arrives                        |
| -------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------- |
| Standard tariff, no certificates                               | Grid average                       | Residual mix, often higher than grid average           | Invoices with consumption in kWh                                | None                                                       |
| Green tariff, certificates cancelled for your consumption      | Grid average, unchanged            | Zero for the covered volume                            | Supplier statement naming cancelled volume, period and registry | High where certificates are annual and from distant plants |
| Green tariff, supplier claims green without cancelling for you | Grid average, unchanged            | Residual mix; the zero is not supportable              | None that supports a zero                                       | Not applicable                                             |
| Unbundled certificates bought and cancelled by you             | Grid average, unchanged            | Zero for the covered volume, if same market and period | Cancellation statements from the registry                       | High                                                       |
| On-site solar consumed on site                                 | Reduces grid electricity purchased | Zero for self-consumed volume                          | Generation meter data; certificates if issued                   | Low; generation and use coincide                           |
| Power purchase agreement with certificates                     | Grid average, unchanged            | Zero for the covered volume                            | Contract plus cancellation records                              | Depends on profile and location of the plant               |

Electricity arrangements and their Scope 2 treatment under the current GHG Protocol guidance. Green Insider, November 2026.

Two rows look identical on an invoice. The second and third differ only in whether certificates were cancelled against your consumption, and that difference decides whether you report zero or the residual mix.

---

## Which number does your customer actually want?

Usually both, and often the location-based one first. The voluntary SME standard's basic module asks for location-based Scope 2, and many customer questionnaires ask for both figures with the method stated.

Reporting only a market-based zero, without the location-based figure beside it, reads as an incomplete answer. Reporting zero labelled simply as Scope 2 reads as a misunderstanding.

The fix costs nothing. Report both numbers, label each with its method and emission factor source, and attach the supplier's cancellation statement to the market-based one. If you calculate in a spreadsheet, that is two extra rows, and it does not justify buying [carbon accounting software](https://www.greeninsider.org/carbon-accounting-software-true-cost/) on its own.

---

## Is hourly matching about to change all this?

Not soon. The GHG Protocol consulted from October 2025 on requiring hourly matching and deliverability, meaning certificates would have to match consumption hour by hour and come from the same grid market.

Corporate support was low: 12 percent of companies supported hourly matching and 82 percent showed low or no support, with deliverability at 19 and 71 percent respectively. As reported on 26 October 2026, the proposal now on the table would make the stricter approach recommended rather than required, allow the current method until a date still to be set, and require companies to disclose which method they use.

A further consultation is planned for the second quarter of 2027, and a joint GHG Protocol and ISO corporate standard is anticipated for the fourth quarter of 2028\. For a small company, the practical conclusion is that annual certificates remain valid for now, but long contracts built on annual certificates from distant plants carry the most future risk.

For where Scope 2 sits among the other scopes, see our explainer on [Scope 1, 2 and 3](https://www.greeninsider.org/scope-1-2-3-emissions-explained/).

---

## Method note

The dual reporting requirement and quality criteria are taken from the GHG Protocol Scope 2 Guidance of 2015\. Guarantee of origin validity follows the Renewable Energy Directive.

National cancellation rules for France and the Netherlands reflect registry practice described in current practitioner analysis. The treatment of REGOs as outside the European certificate system reflects Ofgem's scheme. The status of the Scope 2 revision, including the consultation figures, is taken from reporting dated 26 October 2026 on the GHG Protocol's proposal to its Technical Working Group.

Three points remain open. The Scope 2 revision is a proposal and its transition date is not set.

National cancellation deadlines differ and change, so check your own registry's rules. The exposure column in the table is our assessment of how arrangements would fare under hourly matching and deliverability, not an official classification.

All sources read on 15 November 2026\. This article is not legal or financial advice.

---

## What to do this week

1. Find out which arrangement in the table you actually have, from the contract rather than the marketing.
2. Ask your supplier in writing for the volume of certificates cancelled against your consumption, the period and the registry.
3. Calculate your location-based Scope 2 from invoices and the national grid factor.
4. Calculate your market-based figure, using the residual mix for any volume not covered by cancelled certificates.
5. Report both, labelled, in every questionnaire that asks for Scope 2.

You can read who writes Green Insider, and why, on the [about page](https://www.greeninsider.org/about/).

---

## Frequently asked questions

### Does a green tariff make my Scope 2 zero?

Only your market-based figure, and only for the volume covered by certificates cancelled against your consumption in the same period and market. Your location-based figure does not change.

### What should I ask my energy supplier for?

A written statement of the volume of guarantees of origin or REGOs cancelled on your behalf, the period they cover and the registry where they were cancelled. A brochure or tariff name is not evidence.

### Why is my market-based figure higher than my location-based one?

Because without certificates you use the residual mix, which removes renewable power already claimed by others and is usually higher than the grid average.

### Can I use EU guarantees of origin for a UK site?

Not simply. REGOs in Great Britain sit outside the European certificate system, and certificates generally need to be cancelled in the market where the electricity is consumed.

### Should I avoid long renewable contracts until the rules settle?

Not necessarily, but check the profile and location of the plant. Annual certificates from distant plants carry the most risk if hourly matching and deliverability become the expected method.

---

*Green Insider is independent. No vendor, energy supplier or consultancy paid for a mention in this article, and none was given advance sight of it.*