CLIMATE. CAPITAL. CHANGE.Intelligence for the green economy.
Green Insider

Fifteen questions to ask in a carbon accounting demo, and the answers that should worry you

Fifteen questions to ask in a carbon accounting software demo, covering data, emission factors, audit trail, outputs and exit, with good answers and red flags.

Fifteen questions to ask in a carbon accounting demo, and the answers that should worry you

Short answer. A carbon accounting demo is built to show dashboards, so the useful questions are about what happens behind them: how your data gets in, which emission factors are applied, whether every number traces back to a source, what the outputs look like for the reports you actually file, and what leaving costs. The 15 questions below cover those five areas, with what a good answer sounds like and the red flags to listen for.

Checked on 20 November 2026. Sources and unresolved points are in the method note at the end.

Most software demos follow the same script: a clean dataset, a polished dashboard, a reduction pathway and a report export. None of that tells you how the tool will cope with your invoices, your suppliers and your auditor. Take control of the hour by bringing your own questions and, ideally, your own data.

Key takeaways

  • Bring your own data to the demo. A sample of real invoices reveals most.
  • Ask to see the emission factor. Source, year and version for one line.
  • Trace one number to its source. Audit trails matter more than charts.
  • Match outputs to your actual requests. Questionnaires, banks, the SME standard.
  • Ask about leaving before signing. Export formats and data ownership.

Should you go to a demo at all?

Only once you know what you need the tool to do. If you have one entity, Scope 1 and 2 only and one person owning the data, a well-built spreadsheet may still be enough, as our guide to software vs spreadsheet sets out.

If you are past that point, prepare three things before the call. A list of entities and sites, the Scope 3 categories customers have asked for, and a month of real invoices or meter data you are willing to share.

Ask the vendor to load that sample before or during the demo. How quickly and accurately they do it tells you more than any slide.


What are the 15 questions?

They fall into five areas. The table gives each question, what a good answer sounds like, and the answer that should make you cautious.

# Question A good answer Red flag
Data in
1 How does my energy and fuel data get in? Upload of invoices or exports, utility integrations where available, with a demo on your sample "Our team will handle it" with no tool shown
2 How do you map spend data to Scope 3 categories? Rules you can see and edit, with unmapped lines flagged Fully automatic mapping you cannot review
3 How do suppliers send their own figures? A supplier portal or template, with primary data replacing estimates line by line Supplier data only via paid add-on, not disclosed upfront
Calculation and factors
4 Which emission factor databases do you use, and which version? Named databases with year and version shown on each line "Proprietary factors" with no source
5 Can I override a factor with a supplier-specific one? Yes, with the override logged and the original kept Only by request to support
6 How do you handle location-based and market-based Scope 2? Both calculated, with certificates and contracts recorded as evidence One figure only, or green tariffs set to zero automatically
7 What happens when factors are updated? You choose whether to recalculate, and past reports stay frozen Historical figures change silently
Audit trail
8 Can you trace this total back to the source document? Click through from report to activity line to uploaded invoice Totals with no drill-down
9 Who changed what, and when? A change log by user and date for data and settings No user-level history
10 Has an assurance provider worked with outputs from the tool? Yes, with a description of what auditors were given Vague claims of "audit-ready" with no example
Outputs
11 Can you show the output for a customer questionnaire I received? Figures in the format the request needs, including allocation to one customer Only a generic PDF report
12 Do you support the voluntary SME standard and the formats my bank uses? Mapped datapoints with export, plus guidance on gaps Promised for a future release only
Commercials and exit
13 What is the total cost over three years, with exclusions listed? A written quote covering licence, onboarding, add-ons and support Licence only, the rest "depends"
14 What drives the price up? Clear tiers by entity, site, user or module Price tied to emissions volume or revenue without caps
15 If we leave, what do we take with us? Full export of activity data, factors and calculations in open formats Reports only, or export at extra cost
Fifteen questions to ask in a carbon accounting software demo. Answers and red flags are Green Insider's assessment. Green Insider, November 2026.

You will not get through all fifteen in an hour. Send the list in advance and ask the vendor to structure the demo around it, which also shows how willing they are to work to your agenda.


Which questions matter most for a small company?

Questions 4, 8 and 13. The factor source decides whether your numbers are defensible, the audit trail decides whether anyone can check them, and the three-year cost decides whether the tool is worth having.

The cost question deserves the most persistence. Licences are often the smallest line in a quote, as our analysis of the real software cost shows, and onboarding, Scope 3 modules and supplier portals are where totals grow.

Question 11 is the practical test. If the tool cannot turn your data into the answer a customer actually asked for, it is a reporting tool for someone else's needs.


How should you compare vendors after the demos?

On the same evidence, scored the same way. Ask every vendor the same questions, note the answers in one sheet, and give each area a weight that reflects your situation.

A company answering customer questionnaires will weight outputs and data in heavily. One preparing for external assurance will weight the audit trail. Either way, a vendor that would not load your sample data should score lower than one that did, regardless of the dashboard.

Ask for a trial on your own data before signing anything longer than a year. A short paid pilot costs less than migrating away from the wrong tool.


What should you avoid agreeing to in the demo?

Anything that commits you before you have a written quote. Demo calls often end with an offer that expires at the end of the month; a real price does not depend on deciding this week.

Be careful with headline features you do not need yet. Product carbon footprints, decarbonisation pathways and supplier engagement modules are useful later, but for most small companies the first year is about getting Scope 1, 2 and 3 right for the requests already in the inbox.


Method note

The questions and red flags are Green Insider's assessment, based on how carbon accounting data is structured under the GHG Protocol Corporate Standard, Scope 2 Guidance and Scope 3 Standard, and on common requests in customer questionnaires and bank reviews. No vendor was consulted, and none is named or recommended.

The reference to the voluntary SME standard follows Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1560. The GHG Protocol is revising its Scope 2 guidance, so ask vendors how they plan to handle the changes once final.

All sources read on 19 November 2026. This article is not legal or financial advice.


What to do this week

  1. Write down your entities, sites and the Scope 3 categories customers have asked for.
  2. Prepare a month of real invoices or meter data to share in the demo.
  3. Send the 15 questions to each vendor before the call.
  4. Ask every vendor for a three-year written quote with exclusions.
  5. Score each demo in one sheet using the same weights.

Frequently asked questions

What should I ask in a carbon accounting software demo?

Ask how data gets in, which emission factors are used, whether every figure traces to a source, what the outputs look like for your actual requests, and what leaving costs.

Should I share real data with a vendor?

A small sample, yes, under a confidentiality agreement if needed. It is the fastest way to test whether the tool handles your data.

How many vendors should I see?

Three is usually enough to compare. More than that rarely changes the decision and costs time.

What is the biggest red flag?

Emission factors with no named source or version. If you cannot see where a number comes from, neither can your customer or auditor.

Is a free trial worth it?

Only if you load your own data. A trial on demo data shows the interface, not whether the tool fits your business.


Green Insider is independent. No vendor paid for a mention in this article, none was given advance sight of it, and no vendor is named or recommended here.