Short answer. Scope 4 is an informal name for avoided emissions: the reduction a product or service causes compared with what would have happened without it. It is not a scope in the GHG Protocol and is never subtracted from Scope 1, 2 or 3. The main guidance comes from WBCSD, which sets three gates a company must pass before claiming it, starting with having its own emissions in order.
Checked on 17 November 2026. Sources and unresolved points are in the method note at the end.
Scope 4 appears in sales decks for heat pumps, logistics software and recycled materials, usually as a large number next to a small one. Used carefully, it describes something real. Used carelessly, it is the kind of claim that now attracts regulators and sceptical procurement teams.
Key takeaways
- Scope 4 is not an official scope. The GHG Protocol defines only three.
- It measures emissions avoided elsewhere. Compared with a reference scenario.
- It never reduces your footprint. No netting against Scope 1, 2 or 3.
- WBCSD sets three eligibility gates. Your own house must be in order first.
- Consumer claims face new EU rules. From 27 September 2026.
What does Scope 4 actually mean?
It means avoided emissions. WBCSD defines them as the positive impact created when the greenhouse gas effect of a low-carbon solution is compared with an alternative scenario in which that solution is not used.
A heat pump replacing a gas boiler, software that cuts empty truck journeys, or a recycled material replacing virgin production can all cause emissions to fall somewhere else in the economy. Avoided emissions put a number on that fall.
The label "Scope 4" was popularised from around 2022 to give the idea a familiar shape. It is a misleading shape, because the three real scopes are an inventory of what a company emits, built like any Scope 1 and 2 calculation, and avoided emissions are an estimate of what someone else did not emit.
How is it different from Scope 1, 2 and 3?
In what it measures, how it is calculated and what it can be used for. The table sets the two side by side.
| Question | Scope 1, 2 and 3 | Avoided emissions ("Scope 4") |
|---|---|---|
| What it measures | Emissions your company and value chain actually produce | Emissions that did not happen elsewhere because of your solution |
| Method | Inventory: activity data multiplied by emission factors | Comparison against a counterfactual reference scenario |
| Main standard | GHG Protocol Corporate and Scope 3 Standards | WBCSD Guidance on Avoided Emissions, version 1 in March 2023, updated in 2025 |
| Required in reports? | Scope 1 and 2 widely; Scope 3 for larger companies | Voluntary everywhere |
| Can it lower your footprint? | It is your footprint | No; never subtracted from Scope 1, 2 or 3 |
| Counts toward net zero or science-based targets? | Yes, reductions here count | No |
| Main uncertainty | Data quality and factors | Choice of reference scenario and attribution |
The last row is the important one. An inventory can be wrong because the data is poor, but an avoided emissions figure can be large or small depending almost entirely on what you assume would have happened instead.
Who decides whether a company may claim it?
For now, the company itself, measured against voluntary guidance. The most detailed is WBCSD's Guidance on Avoided Emissions, first published on 22 March 2023 and updated in 2025, which sets three gates that must all be passed.
| Gate | What it asks | Evidence a small company would need |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Climate action credibility | Does the company have its own emissions in order? | A measured Scope 1 and 2 inventory, a reduction target, ideally a validated science-based commitment |
| 2. Climate science alignment | Does the solution have genuine mitigation potential consistent with current climate science? | Evidence the solution fits a low-carbon pathway; fossil fuel activities are excluded |
| 3. Contribution legitimacy | Is the solution's effect direct and significant where the claim is made? | A clear causal link between your product and the reduction, not a minor component of someone else's |
Gate one rules out most small companies that reach for Scope 4 first. If you have not measured your own footprint, do that before calculating anyone else's savings.
Standardisation is still moving. WBCSD has said it wants to give standard setters such as the GHG Protocol and ISO a basis for common approaches, and the GHG Protocol's work on actions and market instruments published a white paper and request for information in March 2026, so the rules may tighten.
How should avoided emissions be presented?
Separately, conservatively and with the method visible. The guidance asks for avoided emissions to be reported as a standalone figure, clearly labelled, never netted against the inventory and kept apart from offsets, credits and removals.
A credible disclosure states the reference scenario, the calculation period, whether figures are forward-looking over a product's lifetime or counted year by year, and the share of revenue that comes from the qualifying products. Without those details a number is not comparable with anyone else's.
The same logic applies to every claim a small company makes about emissions. A figure is only as strong as the evidence behind it, which is also why a green tariff does not automatically justify a zero.
What changed in the EU in September 2026?
Rules on environmental claims to consumers tightened. Under the Directive on Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition, which applies from 27 September 2026, generic environmental claims are prohibited unless recognised excellent environmental performance can be shown, and neutrality claims based on offsetting outside a product's value chain are banned.
Two further rules matter for avoided emissions. Comparative claims must come with clear information about the comparison method, and claims about future environmental performance need a public implementation plan verified by independent experts.
The directive applies to commercial practices aimed at consumers, so purely business-to-business communication sits outside it. Even so, a product claim built on avoided emissions should be written as if a consumer regulator will read it, because marketing material rarely stays in one channel.
If the three real scopes are new to you, start with our explainer on Scope 1, 2 and 3.
Method note
The definition and eligibility gates follow WBCSD's Guidance on Avoided Emissions, version 1.0 published on 22 March 2023 and its 2025 update, as summarised in current practitioner analysis; the full guidance should be consulted before making a claim. The reference to the GHG Protocol's work on actions and market instruments reflects documents it published in March 2026.
The EU rules described are those of the Directive on Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition, in force since 26 March 2024 and applicable from 27 September 2026. How national authorities will treat avoided emissions claims specifically is not yet established, and the evidence column in the gates table is our own assessment.
All sources read on 17 November 2026. This article is not legal or financial advice.
What to do this week
- Measure your own Scope 1 and 2 before calculating avoided emissions.
- Check your solution against the three WBCSD gates and write down the evidence for each.
- Define the reference scenario in one paragraph a sceptical buyer would accept.
- Present any avoided emissions figure separately from your footprint, with the method attached.
- Review consumer-facing claims against the EU rules in force since 27 September 2026.
You can read who writes Green Insider, and why, on the about page.
Frequently asked questions
Is Scope 4 part of the GHG Protocol?
No. The GHG Protocol defines three scopes. Scope 4 is an informal label for avoided emissions, which are guided mainly by WBCSD's voluntary guidance.
Can avoided emissions reduce my carbon footprint?
No. They are reported separately and are never subtracted from Scope 1, 2 or 3, and they do not count toward net zero or science-based targets.
Who should report avoided emissions?
Companies whose products or services directly enable lower emissions elsewhere, and only once they have measured and are managing their own footprint.
How are avoided emissions calculated?
By comparing the emissions of a scenario using your solution with a reference scenario without it. The choice of reference scenario largely determines the result.
Can I use avoided emissions in marketing to consumers?
With care. EU rules in force from 27 September 2026 require comparative claims to explain the method and future claims to rest on a verified plan, and they ban offset-based neutrality claims.
Green Insider is independent. No vendor, provider or consultancy paid for a mention in this article, and none was given advance sight of it.




